Here’s a detailed history of Gallows Hill in Huntington, NY:
📜 Origins and Early References
The hill, located east of Park Avenue and north of East Main Street (intersection with Maple Hill Road), appeared on the 1837 Coastal Survey map as “Gallows Hill”. [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com]
In 19th‑century land deeds, Maple Hill Road was often called the “road to Gallows Hill,” indicating early community usage. [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com]
Revolutionary War: Fort and Executions
During the American Revolution, after occupying Huntington, British forces constructed a fort on the hill to guard the eastern approach to the Town Common. [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com]
In September 1783, two loyalists—Isaac Algar and Nathaniel Parker—were convicted of robbery and assault and subsequently hanged on Gallows Hill, with the British Provost Marshal William Cunningham overseeing the execution. [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com]
Conflicting Legends and Historical Clarification
Over time, conflicting stories emerged. One version claimed the victims were American spies, even featuring British soldiers ceremonially riding to their execution on their own coffins. [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com]
In 1975, Huntington’s Bicentennial Committee installed a marker labeling the site as where “two American martyrs were hanged by the British during the Revolution”. [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com]
However, historian David M. Griffin later confirmed that the victims were British loyalists, not American patriots. [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com]
Name Change and New Marker
As residential development increased in the early 20th century, locals sought a less grim name. They chose Fort Hill, referencing the Revolutionary War fort rather than the site’s grim past. [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com]
On September 23, 2024, a new historical marker was erected at Maple Hill and Fort Hill Roads, correcting the record and acknowledging Algar and Parker as British loyalists executed in 1783. [huntington...istory.com], [newsbreak.com], [huntington...istory.com]
Landmark Markers Today
The original 1975 marker remains on Huntington Bay Road (North of Route 25A), commemorating the executions as “American martyrs”. [hmdb.org], [Huntington...al Markers]
The“Fort Hill” marker at East Main Street and Maple Hill Road highlights the site’s role in the Revolution as the location of a British fort (erected 1977). [hmdb.org], [Huntington...al Markers]
Key Timeline
YearEvent1783Isaac Algar & Nathaniel Parker (British loyalists) hanged [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com].1837Named “Gallows Hill” on coastal survey maps [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com].Circa early 1900sName changed to “Fort Hill” amid residential expansion [huntington...istory.com], [huntington...istory.com].1975Bicentennial marker erected, misidentified victims as American patriots [huntington...istory.com], [hmdb.org], [Huntington...al Markers].1977Fort Hill outpost marker installed near East Main & Maple Hill Roads [hmdb.org], [Huntington...al Markers].2024 (Sept 23)New marker corrects record, names victims and clarifies their loyalist status [huntington...istory.com], [newsbreak.com], [huntington...istory.com].
In Summary
Gallows Hill, now known as Fort Hill, transitioned from a notorious execution site to a revolutionary fort location in public memory. Despite early misinterpretations of the hanging victims' identities, modern scholarship and updated historical markers now accurately honor its complex past.