Barn from the Newton Homestead was located near where the Meat Farms store on Portion Road at Lake Ronkonkoma is now - H Sauter.
More info…
Here’s the historical overview of Caleb Newton Farm in Ronkonkoma, NY:
🏡 Caleb Newton Farm (Established 1796)
Location & Marker
A New York State historical marker, installed January 1, 2021 at the intersection of Lake Shore Road and Portion Road in Lake Ronkonkoma, commemorates the site of “Caleb Newton Farm 1796.” [lakeronkon...ission.org], [hmdb.org]Early Significance
On this farm, Caleb Newton hosted the first church in Ronkonkoma (a Methodist congregation) from 1796 until 1834, a foundation that led to what became known locally as the “5 Corners” Methodist Church. [hmdb.org]
Newton Family Heritage
Caleb Newton Sr. (1730–1787)
Born in Brookhaven, Suffolk County.
Married Nancy “Anna” Blydenburgh (~1753).
Father to several children, including Caleb Newton Jr.
He died August 11, 1787 in Ronkonkoma and is buried in Newton Cemetery, Lake Grove. [findagrave.com]
Caleb Newton Jr. (1763–1844)
Born in Ronkonkoma; married Elizabeth Loree around 1783.
Had at least ten children—including Caleb Newton III (1793–1870).
Died February 21, 1844 in Ronkonkoma; also buried in Newton Cemetery. [ancestors....search.org], [ancestors....search.org]
Caleb Newton III (1793–1870)
Born November 3, 1793 in Ronkonkoma, later moved west.
Married Mary Tuttle in 1816.
Passed away December 10, 1870 in Killawog, Broome County. [ancestors....search.org]
Evolution: From Farm to Community Landmark
In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the Newton family's presence in Ronkonkoma evolved beyond agriculture:
Newton Garage (Early 1900s)
Owned by Elbert Hollis Newton’s sons, Sumner (1887–1958) and Richard Bang Newton (1889–1945), this auto service station stood at Ronkonkoma Avenue and Portion Road.
• Served automobiles (Model T, Model A) and offered repair services—a technological and commercial shift from farming.
• Sumner, trained by Henry Ford and later Locomobile Company, and Richard, active in community roles and WWII service, ran the operation into the mid-20th century. [messengerpapers.com]
Timeline at a Glance
PeriodEvent1796Farm established; first church congregation held in farmhouse (1796–1834).1787–1844Lives and deaths of Caleb Newton Sr. and Jr. in the Ronkonkoma area.Early 1900sNewton family founds and operates an early auto garage and gas station.2021Official historical marker erected honoring the farm and its role in founding the church. [lakeronkon...ission.org], [hmdb.org]
🌳 Legacy & Community Impact
The farm was pivotal in the spiritual and civic development of Ronkonkoma, marking the roots of Methodism in the region.
Transition to the Newton Garage underscores how later generations adapted to technological changes, continuing the family's community presence.
Today, the historical marker offers a tangible connection to both the family’s early agricultural legacy and the birth of a local church.