Here’s a detailed look into the early history of duck farming around Shirley (Mastic-Shirley) on Long Island:
🦆 Early Beginnings of Duck Farming on Long Island
In 1873, the Pekin duck breed was introduced from China, revolutionizing duck farming in the area with meatier birds that matured quickly. The temperate Long Island climate, abundant freshwater, and proximity to New York City made the region ideal for duck production. [scifisland.com], [southoldhi...orical.org]
By 1900, roughly 30 duck farms were operating across areas like Moriches, Eastport, and Riverhead. Production soared—from 200,000 ducks in 1897 up to 2 million annually by 1922. [southoldhi...orical.org], [scifisland.com]
At its peak in the 1940s, nearly 100 duck farms dotted Long Island’s East End, producing nearly half of the nation’s duck meat. [tastyduck.com], [southoldhi...orical.org]
Notable Early Duck Individual: George Pugsley’s Farm
In Riverhead (just west of Shirley), a historic marker notes that George Pugsley raised Pekin ducks from around 1909 to 1920. [hmdb.org], [wgpfoundation.org]
His duck ranch included a“picking house”, which suffered a fire in November 1919. Shortly after, Pugsley sold the farm for about $30,000. [wgpfoundation.org]
Around 1931, Martin Maurer—a fellow duck farmer—constructed the famous Big Duck roadside stand nearby, a 28-foot-tall duck-shaped structure used to sell his duck products. It became an iconic landmark in the region. [wgpfoundation.org], [tastyduck.com]
Duck Farming in the Shirley/Mastic Area
Though most records focus on Riverhead, duck farming was widespread throughout Suffolk County, including areas around Shirley and Mastic.
Modern heritage tours of the Mastics‑Moriches‑Shirley area highlight local historical sites, including the Robinson Duck Farm, now transformed into a dog park, preserving the area's duck farming legacy. [uploads.kn...ghtlab.com]
Decline, Legacy & Preservation
Starting in the 1960s, environmental regulations, rising land costs, taxes, and urban development began to overwhelm the industry.
By the late 20th century, almost all farms had closed, been sold off, or shifted out of state. The once-booming industry dwindled from ~100 farms to just one remaining as of the early 21st century—Crescent Duck Farm in Aquebogue (Central Long Island). [tastyduck.com], [danspapers.com], [southoldhi...orical.org]
Cultural artifacts and landmarks remain: the Big Duck (Flanders) is now on the National Register of Historic Places, while the Long Island Ducks baseball and hockey teams nod to the region’s duck-farming heritage. [tastyduck.com], [danspapers.com]
Timeline Summary
1873 9 Pekin ducks imported from China—start of Long Island duck farming [scifisland.com], [southoldhi...orical.org]
~1909–1920 George Pugsley raises ducks near Riverhead/Shirley [hmdb.org], [wgpfoundation.org]
1919 Fire damages Pugsley’s picking house—farm sold soon after [wgpfoundation.org]
1931 Big Duck roadside stand built nearby [wgpfoundation.org], [tastyduck.com]
1940s Industry peaks: ~100 farms, ~50% of national duck production [tastyduck.com], [southoldhi...orical.org]
1960s–1980s Decline continues due to regulations & rising costs; exodus of farmers [danspapers.com], [suffolkcountyny.gov]
Today Only Crescent Duck Farm remains; landmarks like the Big Duck and Robinson Duck Farm dog park preserve legacy [danspapers.com], [uploads.kn...ghtlab.com]
Duck farming played a major role in the region’s rural and economic identity in the early 20th century. Although most farms near Shirley are long gone, the area's history endures in structures, cultural memories, and preserved sites like the Robinson Duck Farm park and the Big Duck.