Here’s a detailed history of the Osterby House, located at the northeast corner of Fort Salonga Road (Route 25A) and Makamah Road in the hamlet of Fort Salonga, just east of Northport, NY:
🏡 Origins & Early Construction
The site originally included a large 18th-century house, possibly associated with a Presbyterian church built there in the late 1700s (later relocated in 1829). [huntington...istory.com], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
Real-estate records commonly date the core of the current structure to the late 1700s or early 1800s, with some records suggesting around 1837. [finditlongisland.com], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
The Osterby Family Era
Danish immigrants Bernhard (“Bernard”) Osterby (born 1834), a decorated veteran of the Danish army, and his wife Bentte Marie Osterby (13 years his junior) arrived in the U.S. in 1881. [huntington...istory.com], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
In March 1890, Bernard purchased the four-acre property from the heirs of Methodist minister Moses Rogers for $450, and soon transferred it to his wife. [huntington...istory.com], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
Boarding House & Saloon Activities
The Osterbys operated the house as an informal boarding house and tavern for nearby brickyard workers. Bernard frequently sold beer and liquor without a license, leading to multiple legal issues:
1888 arrest for illegal liquor sales and threats (charges later dismissed). [huntington...istory.com], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
Convicted in 1890, fined $50. [huntington...istory.com], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
In 1896, a violent knife fight occurred on the premises between boarders. [huntington...istory.com]
The 1900 Fire & Rebuilding
On January 15, 1900, a catastrophic fire—possibly sparked by a gas lamp explosion—destroyed the house. Fifteen boarders were inside; one immigrant (mid-30s) died, and Mrs. Osterby suffered serious burns while rescuing a child. [huntington...istory.com], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
That same year:
The house was rebuilt using brick, a logical choice given proximity to brickyards and the severity of the fire. [huntington...istory.com]
Mortgage and deed documents include a peculiar restriction barring liquor sales, transferred via a deed from Lewis Smith back to the Osterbys. [huntington...istory.com]
Later Ownership & Preservation
Bernard Osterby died in May 1910. [farmingdal...ogspot.com], [huntington...istory.com]
Bentte Marie remarried (to John Merry) before selling the property in 1921 to Raymond Bloomer, retaining a life estate. [huntington...istory.com], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
After passing through various hands, Eugene Mudge purchased it in 1957, remodeling and expanding it in the 1970s. [farmingdal...ogspot.com], [huntington...istory.com]
In 2000, new owners acquired and updated the kitchen; the distinctive small brick structure remains intact. [farmingdal...ogspot.com], [huntington...istory.com]
In 2011, the Town of Huntington installed a historical marker summarizing its colorful past—including brickworkers, illegal liquor sales, knife fights, and the deadly 1900 fire. [hmdb.org], [farmingdal...ogspot.com]
📜 Why It Matters
One of the region’s earliest surviving structures—showcasing architectural evolution from an 18th-century farmhouse to a turn‑of‑the‑century brick boarding house.
Reflects late 19th-century immigrant life, small-scale tavern operations, and community tensions in Fort Salonga/Northport.
Its 1900 blaze, tragic fire casualties, and subsequent reconstruction provide a poignant window into the era’s social and economic dynamics.